Know what is the In thing now

Menstrual leave: The Pros and Cons of it

Pros and cons of Menstrual leave

Spain recently became the first country in Europe to introduce paid menstrual leave. It joins other nations such as Indonesia, Zambia, Taiwan, South Korea, and Japan that have implemented similar policies. The new law, which was approved by the Spanish parliament in February, allows women to request three days of paid leave per menstrual cycle.

This policy is part of a broader package on sexual and reproductive rights in Spain, which includes initiatives to expand abortion access. However, it has sparked intense debate regarding its potential impact on women in the workplace. Campaigners in the UK have also been advocating for similar legislation. They emphasize the need to understand and support the challenges faced by individuals who menstruate in the workplace. The Labour Party has also proposed a menopause action plan, which could potentially include paid time off for women.

Let’s examine some of the pros and cons associated with menstrual leave policies:

Pros include:

Raises awareness
Supporters argue that such policies can advance gender equality by normalizing menstruation. Spain’s new law has generated significant public discussion and raised awareness about the rights related to menstrual health. This dialogue is essential, considering that severe period pains, known as dysmenorrhea, affect about one-third of women and can include symptoms such as vomiting, diarrhea, headaches, and fever.
Could combat absences
Studies have shown that a significant number of women experience intense period pain that hinders their ability to carry out daily tasks. Menstruation-related symptoms can lead to lost productivity, with presenteeism (attending work despite being unwell) having a more significant impact than absenteeism (taking days off). Creating a more supportive workplace environment that acknowledges and offers support for these issues could alleviate the negative effects on women’s careers and overall well-being.
Helps endometriosis sufferers
Paid menstrual leave can provide much-needed relief for individuals suffering from endometriosis, a chronic condition that affects approximately one in ten women. The severe pain associated with endometriosis often forces employees to take days off work. By providing paid leave, employers can support those with this condition, allowing them to manage their symptoms more effectively and reducing the impact on their careers and well-being.

Cons could be:

Could increase discrimination
Critics express concerns that menstrual leave policies might reinforce negative gender stereotypes and notions of biological determinism, potentially leading to increased discrimination against women in the workplace. Labeling menstruation as a form of debility or disability could perpetuate the stereotype that it makes women weaker and less productive. It may also contribute to biases in performance reviews and promotions, especially in demanding roles.
Potential access issues
To apply for paid menstrual leave in Spain, employees need to provide a doctor’s note each time. This requirement might discourage some women from seeking access to this benefit. Additionally, it is unclear how the new law will apply to freelancers or what changes companies and sectors will need to make to comply. Some individuals entitled to menstrual leave may choose not to take it due to fear of judgment from colleagues, as many have already normalized working through pain and discomfort.
Legal and privacy issues
Critics argue that menstrual leave policies might be discriminatory toward men and women who do not menstruate, as they would not be entitled to the same benefits. Concerns have also been raised about privacy implications, particularly regarding how women may need to demonstrate their symptoms to claim leave. This could create challenges for transgender men who still menstruate or infringe on the privacy of women who have experienced early menopause. Additionally, some argue that severe period symptoms should already qualify for paid time off under existing laws.

Time to find the perfect balance

It’s important to note that the effectiveness and implications of menstrual leave policies are still being studied, and their impact may vary depending on cultural, social, and legal contexts. Ongoing evaluation and adjustments to these policies will help ensure they strike a balance between supporting individuals’ needs and addressing potential challenges.

You might also be interested in

Get the word out!